ランク付けの基準は、音楽性の高さと後世に与えた影響力。 とりあえずランク表を自分なりに作ってみたので、 これを土台に皆で完璧なランク表を作りましょう。 S The Beatles,The Velvet Underground,Joy Division, Pink Floyd,CAN,The Jimi Hendrix Experience,The Doors Sly & The Family Stone A+ The Rolling Stones,The Who,The Kinks,The Beach Boys The Smiths,The Police,New Order,King Krimson,Pixies My Bloody Valentine,Pavement,The Cure A Led Zeppelin,The Band,Kraftwerk,Radiohead,XTC,Sex Pistols The Clash,The Zombies,The Animals,Neu!,The Grateful Dead Cream,T-Rex,R.E.M.,The Byrds B+ Nirvana,Ramones,Dinosaur Jr.,The Jesus and Mary Chain Alice In Chains,Sonic Youth,The Stone Roses,Yes B The Jam,Ride,Electric Light Orchestra,Public Image Ltd Gang of Four,Queen,10cc,Specials,Yardbirds C Oasis,Blur,Travis,Talking Heads,Primal Scream,Pearl Jam, Sparks,The La`s,The Libertines D The Strokes,The White Stripes,The Flaming Lips Arktic Monkeys,Arcade Fire E The Music,Franz Ferdinand,Klaxsons,MGMT,Vampire Weekend Weezer,The Horrors F Green Day,My Chemical Romance,The Offspring,Linkin Park
2 :
じゃあ俺は S The Beatles,The Velvet Underground,Joy Division, Pink Floyd,CAN,The Jimi Hendrix Experience,The Doors Sly & The Family Stone A+ The Rolling Stones,The Who,The Kinks,The Beach Boys The Smiths,The Police,New Order,King Krimson,Pixies My Bloody Valentine,Pavement,The Cure A Led Zeppelin,The Band,Kraftwerk,Radiohead,XTC,Sex Pistols The Clash,The Zombies,The Animals,Neu!,The Grateful Dead Cream,T-Rex,R.E.M.,The Byrds B+ Nirvana,Ramones,Dinosaur Jr.,The Jesus and Mary Chain Alice In Chains,Sonic Youth,The Stone Roses,Yes B The Jam,Ride,Electric Light Orchestra,Public Image Ltd Gang of Four,Queen,10cc,Specials,Yardbirds C Oasis,Blur,Travis,Talking Heads,Primal Scream,Pearl Jam, Sparks,The La`s,The Libertines D The Strokes,The White Stripes,The Flaming Lips Arktic Monkeys,Arcade Fire E The Music,Franz Ferdinand,Klaxsons,MGMT,Vampire Weekend Weezer,The Horrors F Green Day,My Chemical Romance,The Offspring,Linkin Park
3 :
俺はこうだな S The Beatles,The Velvet Underground,Joy Division, Pink Floyd,CAN,The Jimi Hendrix Experience,The Doors Sly & The Family Stone A+ The Rolling Stones,The Who,The Kinks,The Beach Boys The Smiths,The Police,New Order,King Krimson,Pixies My Bloody Valentine,Pavement,The Cure A Led Zeppelin,The Band,Kraftwerk,Radiohead,XTC,Sex Pistols The Clash,The Zombies,The Animals,Neu!,The Grateful Dead Cream,T-Rex,R.E.M.,The Byrds B+ Nirvana,Ramones,Dinosaur Jr.,The Jesus and Mary Chain Alice In Chains,Sonic Youth,The Stone Roses,Yes B The Jam,Ride,Electric Light Orchestra,Public Image Ltd Gang of Four,Queen,10cc,Specials,Yardbirds C Oasis,Blur,Travis,Talking Heads,Primal Scream,Pearl Jam, Sparks,The La`s,The Libertines D The Strokes,The White Stripes,The Flaming Lips Arktic Monkeys,Arcade Fire E The Music,Franz Ferdinand,Klaxsons,MGMT,Vampire Weekend Weezer,The Horrors F Green Day,My Chemical Romance,The Offspring,Linkin Park
S The Beatles,The Velvet Underground,Pink Floyd, The Jimi Hendrix Experience, Sly & The Family Stone A+ The Rolling Stones,The Who,The Kinks,The Beach Boys The Smiths,The Police,New Order,King Krimson,Pixies My Bloody Valentine,Pavement,The Cure,Joy Division,The Doors,CAN A Led Zeppelin,The Band,Kraftwerk,Radiohead,XTC,Sex Pistols The Clash,The Zombies,The Animals,Neu!,The Grateful Dead Cream,T-Rex,R.E.M.,The Byrds B+ Nirvana,Ramones,Dinosaur Jr.,The Jesus and Mary Chain Alice In Chains,Sonic Youth,The Stone Roses,Yes B The Jam,Ride,Electric Light Orchestra,Public Image Ltd Gang of Four,Queen,10cc,Specials,Yardbirds,Smashing Pampkins C Oasis,Blur,Travis,Talking Heads,Primal Scream,Pearl Jam, Sparks,The La`s,The Libertines,Aerosmith,U2,Coldplay,Massive Attack D The Strokes,The White Stripes,The Flaming Lips Arktic Monkeys,Arcade Fire,Red Hot Chili Peppers, Rage Against The Machine,MUSE,Pet Shop Boys,Daft Punk E The Music,Franz Ferdinand,Klaxsons,MGMT,Vampire Weekend Weezer,The Horrors,Bloc Party F Green Day,My Chemical Romance,The Offspring,Linkin Park ここまでの意見を参考に>>1のランクを改変してみた。
26 :
オッサン乙
27 :
年代別にわけただけだろ
28 :
ベルベッツの評価が高すぎる
29 :
ピンクフロイドがSって妥当なのか?
30 :
ジミヘンとビートルズがS 残りは知らんヽ(´ー`)ノ
31 :
音楽性の高さと後世に与えた影響力って比例しないから難しいよね。
32 :
Bランクあたりからおかしい
33 :
ピクシーズたけえなwwwww いや大好きなんだけどさ
34 :
S The Beatles, The Jimi Hendrix Experience,
A+ The Rolling Stones,The Velvet Underground, Pink Floyd, Sly & The Family Stone
A Led Zeppelin,The Band,Kraftwerk,Radiohead,XTC Oasis,Talking Heads,Nirvana,U2,New Order ↑ ちょっと直したらすっきりした。
【S 】The Beatles, The Jimi Hendrix Experience 【A+】The Kinks, The Beach Boys, Ramones, Sex Pistols, CAN, The Smiths, Pixies, Sly & The Family Stone 【A 】T.Rex, King Crimson, Led Zeppelin, My Bloody Valentine, The Band, XTC, The Grateful Dead, The Stone Roses 【B+】The Rolling Stones, Pink Floyd, Kraftwerk, Cream, The Velvet Underground, Radiohead, Nirvana, R.E.M., The Clash, Dinosaur Jr., The Jesus and Mary Chain, Alice In Chains, The Byrds, Queen 【B 】The Doors, The Animals, Neu!, Electric Light Orchestra, Public Image Ltd, Gang of Four, Talking Heads, The Specials 【C 】The Police, Green Day, Oasis, Weezer, Primal Scream, Pearl Jam, Sparks, 10cc, Pavement, The Cure, Sonic Youth, The Yardbirds, The Flaming Lips 【D 】The Who, Joy Division, New Order, The La`s, The Zombies, Blur, Travis, The Strokes, The White Stripes, Arcade Fire, Vampire Weekend, Linkin Park, Yes
【E 】The Jam, The Music, Ride, The Libertines, MGMT, The Offspring 【F 】My Chemical Romance, Klaxsons, The Horrors, Arktic Monkeys, Franz Ferdinand とりあえず>>1に追加はしないで並び替えた。あと見やすくした。
【S 】The Beatles, The Jimi Hendrix Experience 【A+】The Rolling Stones,The Velvet Underground, Pink Floyd, Sly & The Family Stone,CAN 【A 】The Band,The Beach Boys,The Who,The Kinks,The Smiths,The Cure, Led Zeppelin,Sex Pistols,Kraftwerk,King Crimson,The Stooges,Pixies 【B+】Joy Division,New Order,XTC,My Bloody Valentine,The Clash, The Police,R.E.M.,The Doors,Talking Heads,Radiohead 【B 】Nirvana,The Stone Roses,The Jam,Boredoms,Pavement,Wire, Television,The Fall,Dinosaur Jr.,Sonic Youth,U2 The Jesus and Mary Chain,Gang of Four,Roxy Music,Public Image Ltd 【C 】Coldplay,Oasis,Blur,Primal Scream,Pearl Jam,Aerosmith,The Verve, The Smashing Pampkins,Travis,Killing Joke,Massive Attack,Bauhaus 【D 】Red Hot Chili Peppers,Arctic Monkeys,The Strokes,Animal Corrective, Golliraz,The Flaming Lips,The La`s,Muse 【E 】The White Stripes,The Libertines,The Vines,The Hives,Bloc Party, Franz Ferdinand,Arcade Fire,Super Furry Animals,MGMT, Manic Street Preachers,The Killers,Kasabian,The Mars Volta 【F 】The Music,Weezer,Green Day,Vampire Weekend, The Fratellis 【G 】Linkin Park,Sum41,My Chemical Romance,The Offspring, System Of A Down,Slipknot これでどうだ?
64 :
あっ! ボウイもいないし、イーノもいない!!
65 :
RATMは?ジャミロクワイ、NIN辺りとDくらいかな?
66 :
【S 】The Beatles,The Beach Boys, The Jimi Hendrix Experience,(新)ザッパバンド The Velvet Underground,Pink Floyd,(新)ブラックサバス 【A+】The Rolling Stones, Sly & The Family Stone,CAN ,Led Zeppelin,Kraftwerk,King Crimson,The Clash 【A 】The Band,The Who,The Kinks,The Smiths,The Cure,(新)YES Sex Pistols,Kraftwerk,King Crimson,The Stooges,Pixies 【B+】Joy Division,New Order,XTC,My Bloody Valentine, Sonic Youth,Public Image Ltd The Police,R.E.M.,The Doors,Talking Heads,Radiohead ,Gang of Four,(新)ザ・ポップグループ (新)メタリカ(新)PANTERA 【B 】Nirvana,Weezer,The Stone Roses,The Jam,Boredoms,Pavement,Wire, Television,The Fall,Dinosaur Jr,U2,(新)ガンズアンドローゼス The Jesus and Mary Chain,Roxy Music,(新)JAPAN(新)アリスインチェインズ (新)フェイスノーモア{マイクパットン関連}(新)ナインインチネイルズ (新)零時アゲインストザマシーン(新)KORN (新)ポーティスヘッド 【C 】Oasis,Blur,Green Day,Primal Scream,Pearl Jam,Aerosmith,Red Hot Chili Peppers The Smashing Pampkins,Killing Joke,Massive Attack,Bauhaus,(新)ザ・プロディジー
【D 】The Strokes,Animal Corrective, The Flaming Lips,The La`s,Muse,Arcade Fire The Mars Volta,Manic Street Preachers,System Of A Down 【E 】The White Stripes,The Libertines,The Vines,The Hives,Bloc Party,Slipknot Super Furry Animals,MGMT,ザ・ヴァーヴ, Vampire Weekend,The Offspring The Killers,Kasabian,Travis,Arctic Monkeys,Golliraz,The Music, 【F 】Linkin Park,Sum41,My Chemical Romance,
売上、音楽性、後世への影響力で並べてみた。 「S」 The Beatles,The Velvet Underground,The Rolling Stones Pink Floyd, 「A+」 Jimi Hendrix Experience,Sex Pistols 「A」 The Police,Sly & The Family Stone,My Bloody Valentine,Kraftwerk The Beach Boys,Led Zeppelin,The Clash,King Krimson, Nirvana,Queen,The Smiths,Radiohead,The Doors 「B」 The Who,The Band,CAN,Gang of Four,Pavement,Joy Division,New Order, Public Image Ltd Oasis,Arcade Fire,Arctic Monkeys,Ramones,Sonic Youth,The Cure The Grateful Dead,Deep Purple 「C」 The Stone Roses,Talking Heads,The Strokes,The Libertines,White Stripes,Interpol The Jesus and Mary Chain,Nine Inchi Nails,animal collective, R.E.M., Pearl Jam,Ride,T-Rex,The Kinks,Electric Light Orchestra, Specials,Pixies,The Byrds,XTC,Television 「D」 MGMT,Vampire Weekend,The Jam,Primal Scream,Weezer,The Flaming Lips Green Day,The La`s,Horrors 「E」 Dinosaur Jr.,Alice In Chains,Franz Ferdinand, The Music,Korn,Foo Fighters 「F」 Klaxsons,My Chemical Romance,Linkin Park
73 :
ディープパープルはAいっちゃってもいいと思うぞ 功績はツェッペリンといい勝負だと思う
74 :
「S」 The Beatles,The Velvet Underground, 「A+」 Jimi Hendrix Experience,Can,The Beach Boys,The Rolling Stones, Pink Floyd,King Krimson, 「A」 Sly & The Family Stone,Kraftwerk,Sonic Youth, The Beach Boys,Led Zeppelin,The Clash,Joy Division, The Smiths,Radiohead,The Doors,XTC,Television,Talking Heads, 「B」 The Who,The Band,Gang of Four,Pavement, Ramones,The Cure,Pixies,Sex Pistols, The Grateful Dead,My Bloody Valentine,Dinosaur Jr.,Nirvana, 「C」 The Stone Roses,The Strokes,The Libertines,White Stripes,Interpol The Jesus and Mary Chain,Nine Inchi Nails,animal collective, R.E.M., Pearl Jam,Ride,T-Rex,The Kinks,Electric Light Orchestra, Specials,The Byrds,Arcade Fire,Arctic Monkeys, Public Image Ltd New Order,Queen,The Police 「D」 MGMT,Vampire Weekend,The Jam,Primal Scream,Weezer,The Flaming Lips The La`s,Horrors,Deep Purple 「E」 ,Alice In Chains,Franz Ferdinand, The Music,Korn,Foo Fighters,Oasis,Green Day, 「F」 Klaxsons,My Chemical Romance,Linkin Park, 音楽性>影響力>売上で考えてみた
ランク以前にSly & The Family Stoneとかロックバンドと言えねえのが混ざってるだろw 聴いたことないバンドとか無理して入れんなw
93 :
スライは入る ファンクというよりは人種混成ロックバンド
94 :
「S」 The Beatles,The Velvet Underground, 「A+」 Jimi Hendrix Experience,Can,The Beach Boys,Pink Floyd,King Krimson, 「A」 Sonic Youth,Kraftwerk,The Beach Boys,Led Zeppelin,The Clash, Joy Division,The Smiths,Radiohead,The Doors,XTC,Television, Talking Heads,The Rolling Stones,Fugazi, 「B」 The Who,The Band,Gang of Four,Pavement,Neu! The Cure,Pixies,Sex Pistols,Slint,Wilco,Ramones, The Grateful Dead,My Bloody Valentine,Dinosaur Jr., 「C」 The Stone Roses,The Strokes,The Libertines,White Stripes,Interpol The Jesus and Mary Chain,Nine Inchi Nails,animal collective,Nirvana, R.E.M., Pearl Jam,Ride,T-Rex,The Kinks,Electric Light Orchestra, Specials,The Byrds,Arcade Fire,Public Image Ltd New Order,Queen,The Police,Sigur Ros,The Jon Spencer Blues Explosion, 「D」 MGMT,Vampire Weekend,The Jam,Arctic Monkeys,Primal Scream,Weezer,The Flaming Lips The La`s,Horrors,Deep Purple, 「E」 Alice In Chains,Franz Ferdinand, The Music,Korn,Foo Fighters, 「F」 Klaxsons,My Chemical Romance,Linkin Park,Oasis,Green Day,